Anthony's Menu (Update 2026)

Anthony's in New Market serves classic New York-style pizza. Expect bold flavors in every slice, from the cheesy goodness of the Cheese Pizza to the hearty Meat Lover's variety.

Cravings straddle appetizers and entrees—the Garlic Knots are a local favorite, often paired with savory marinara. Each bite introduces a warm, buttery touch perfect for sharing or devouring solo.

Explore a range of homemade pasta dishes like Lasagna and Spaghetti Marinara, or opt for hearty Calzones and Strombolis. Desserts like Cannoli and Cheese Cake provide a sweet ending after a satisfying meal.

Anthony's Menu image 1
Anthony's

Anthony's Interior, Food, Ambiance

Walking through Anthony's entrance feels welcoming, characterized by its warm, family-friendly atmosphere. Dim lighting and Italian decor set the mood, making it perfect for a casual dinner or a special occasion.

The layout provides comfortable seating for large groups and cozy corners for romantic dinners. Friendly waitstaff elevate the experience, always ready to recommend the best dishes or pour a glass of sweet tea.

Locals often gather here not just for the food but for the community spirit. Anthony's serves as a gathering spot, where conversations flow as easily as the delicious food.

Anthony's

About Anthony's Food and Specialties

Anthony's captures the essence of Italian-American cooking, focusing on freshness and bold flavors. The menu includes 83 unique dishes that appeal to diverse palates, fitting for families and solo diners alike.

Pizza is a cornerstone here, with options like Sicilian Cheese and Supreme Pizza. The crust stands out, crispy on the outside yet soft and flavorful on the inside. Customers rave about the perfect balance.

For those seeking appetizers, Mozzarella Sticks and Pepperoni Rolls are popular choices. Hearty salads cater to lighter appetites without sacrificing flavor, while hearty pasta entrees provide a satisfying meal.

Anthony's

Anthony's Pizza Restaurant stands firm in its commitment to serving delicious food made with care. The specialty lies in crafting genuine New York-style pizza that captures the essence of traditional Italian cuisine. Every dish is prepared with attention to detail, ensuring flavors resonate well with every bite. The vision focuses on creating a dining experience that celebrates community connections through food.

Offering a diverse menu allows for exploration, whether you wish to indulge in pasta entrees, hearty strombolis, or comforting baked dishes. Anthony's serves as a gathering place where delicious food and great company meet.

With plans for community involvement and enhancing the menu, Anthony's continually focuses on how to connect better with patrons. Their commitment ensures that each visit feels special and satisfying, making it a staple in New Market's food scene.